Leave Room for the Tutu: Edward Macdonald on Holding Space in Coaching
The Spaciousness Advantage: How to create choice under pressure
IGNITE: Global Gathering 2026 · Denver, Block Two · Friday, October 2, 2026
The short version: Clients often ask for help with the wrong problem, and holding space in coaching gives them room to find an answer neither coach nor client could have planned.
From the Spark Talk The Spaciousness Advantage at IGNITE: Global Gathering, Denver, October 2026
Edward Macdonald, a CTEDU trainer many attendees knew from class, opened his Spark Talk at IGNITE: Global Gathering with a story about his three-year-old daughter and what holding space in coaching looks like in practice. She ran up to him in tears, wearing boots and holding a pair of tights. She couldn't get her pants on. The fix was obvious, and he almost made it for her. Instead, with no hurry that day, he got curious, asked her what she needed, and held space. She looked at the pants, then the boots, back and forth, then dropped everything and ran off.
Boots and pants
Macdonald paused the story there, because clients do the same thing. They arrive wearing boots: identities, ambitions, and values they are attached to and don't want to take off. They are also holding pants: constraints, expectations, and requirements that won't fit over those boots. Then they ask for help getting the pants on.
Coaches get very good at working with pants and boots. We ask sharp questions, brainstorm, and sometimes coax the pants on without tearing them. Macdonald's point is that we may be solving the wrong problem.
It's really more about space than it is about boots.
Holding space is where insight happens
Spaciousness is a pattern Macdonald sees everywhere. A conversation needs a container. Music depends on its rests. Outer space and the inside of an atom are both mostly empty. He also sees it on EEG. The first time he watched a client's brain during coaching, a moment of insight arrived with a spike in alpha waves, the relaxed, present state of being rather than thinking. He pointed to researchers Kounios and Beeman, whose work on insight describes a similar pattern: an alpha burst that quiets thinking before a jump into the gamma activity linked to an aha moment.
Insight needs less competition, and coaching sessions are crowded. The client brings pressure to solve a problem. The coach brings pressure to do well, look professional, and provide value. Two nervous systems in one conversation can leave very little room.
The tutu
A few minutes after running off, his daughter came back grinning, wearing a tutu. Macdonald said he could replay that moment a thousand times and never think to suggest it. He had misunderstood the problem. The real problem was simpler: she needed something to wear and wanted to keep her boots on.
Coaches misread the problem often, he said. Neither the coach nor the client knows what the client's tutu is, and the client can only find it with space. He led the room through a quick exercise: name a current challenge, identify your boots and your pants, then ask what you actually need. Whether or not a breakthrough came, the lesson was to notice how fast the mind jumps to thinking.
His challenge to coaches: listen for the boots, listen for the pants, and leave some space for the tutu.
Three questions to consider
- In a challenge you are facing now, what are your boots, the things you aren't willing to take off, and what are the pants that won't fit over them?
- In your sessions, how much of the space is taken up by your own pressure to help, impress, or add value?
- When was the last time you thought you understood a client's problem and turned out to be wrong, and what made room for the real answer to appear?
Read the full transcript
Edited for readability. Filler words and false starts removed.
Hi. Hi. It’s a lot of fun to see you all in person. I’ve taught a lot of you over screens, so thank you.
A few years ago, one of my daughters taught me something about coaching that changed my career, so I’m going to share it with you. A few of you have heard this story, but not the why behind it, so you get to hear that today.
I was sitting on the couch, and my three-year-old came running in with big tears in her eyes. She was wearing a pair of boots, and she was holding a pair of tights, like this, and crying big tears. “What’s wrong, honey?” “I can’t get my pants on.”
I solved the problem. Pretty sure you see it too. And I almost fixed it for her. I’m really glad I didn’t, because I use this story all the time.
We weren’t in a hurry that day, so instead of solving the problem, I just got curious. I did what we do. I asked her a question. I held space. “I’m sorry, honey.” I forget the exact question, but it was something along the lines of “What’s wrong?” or “How can I help?” or “What do you need?”
And she paused. Looked at the pants. Looked at the boots. Looked at the pants. Looked at the boots. Looked at the pants. Looked at the boots. Then she dropped them and ran away.
I’m going to pause the story there. Just leave us there for a minute, because there’s an important lesson here for all of us. Our clients do this all the time. Our clients bring us their boots. Our clients have things they’re attached to, things they don’t want to take off, things that were hard to get on. The obvious solution is to take them off and put the pants on. They’re not taking their boots off. They have identities, ambitions, values.
They also have pants. They have constraints, challenges, expectations, and requirements that don’t fit on over the boots. And they come to us and say, “Help me put my pants on.”
And we get really good at coaching around pants and boots. We ask really good questions about the pants. We challenge and brainstorm, at least about the boots. We may even ask the right combination of questions in just the right way to coax the pants on over the boots, really carefully, without tearing them. But I think we’re solving the wrong problem.
It’s really more about space than it is about boots.
So, space. If you’ve been in my classes, you’ve heard me talk about spaciousness a lot. If you’ve been in my assessments, I’ve talked about spaciousness a lot. I like spaciousness. Spaciousness is a pattern I see everywhere.
In a good conversation: we had a great talk this morning about space and the container. No container, no space, no connection. In music, it’s the space, the rests, that make the music. It’s just noise otherwise.
I zoom out and look at space. We call it space because there’s lots of space in space. That’s why we call it space. I zoom in, and you’ve got electrons spinning around a nucleus, with lots of space in between. There’s space everywhere. I think space matters.
I think what worked that day, and I’ll tell you what happened, is that instead of trying to solve the problem, I was able to leave enough room for her to create new possibilities. Think of it as the big bang of coaching. I’m not kidding.
And it’s not just space in music and atoms. I see this on EEG. The first time I watched a client’s brain while I coached them, there was a moment when the client paused. They had an “aha,” and there was this big alpha spike. Alpha feels relaxed, present, focused. Just this, just now. It’s a lot slower than beta, which is where we think. Alpha’s not thinking. It’s being.
And I’m not the only person who’s seen this. The researchers Kounios and Beeman study moments of insight, and they talk about this too. There’s an alpha burst that suppresses the thinking, and then there’s a burst that slingshots into gamma, where you have insight. You have to have space to have insight.
I think insight needs less competition. And if we’re honest, in a coaching session you have two competing egos putting pressure on a conversation. The client comes into the session with a problem to solve: “Help me put my pants on.” And then we have our own expectations, our own pressure. I want to do a good job. I want to be professional. I want to help. I want to be taken seriously. I want to provide value. So you have two nervous systems competing in a very crowded space, and there’s not a lot of space left.
Which brings me back to what actually happened that day. Instead of taking the pants off, or taking the boots off, putting the pants on, and putting the boots back on again, I held space. She ran off, and she came back a few minutes later with a big grin on her face. And she was wearing a tutu.
We could run that scenario a thousand times, and I would never suggest, “Hey, honey, put on a tutu.” It wasn’t my idea. It wasn’t the problem. I misunderstood the problem. The problem was not “I need to put the pants on over the boots.” That was not the problem. The problem was “I need something to wear, and I don’t want to take the boots off.” And I missed it.
And I’m telling you, that happens often, even with a good time model. We think we know what the client’s problem is. We don’t. We don’t. We’ve got to leave some room for their tutu, because in a coaching conversation, they don’t know what their tutu is. And I don’t know what their tutu is. Nobody knows. They have to go find it, and they’re only going to find it in space.
So we’re going to play a game. You’re going to do what she did. Think of a problem in your life right now: a challenge, an obstacle, something you want to solve, something you’d get coaching on.
- What are your boots? What’s the thing you don’t want to take off? The thing you don’t want to let go of? The thing it took a lot of you to get into, that you just don’t want to separate from?
- Okay, you’ve got your boots. What are your pants? The thing that just doesn’t fit?
Now we’re going to ask a coaching question. I’m going to pause here: the question you ask doesn’t matter as much as we think it does. That’s a different Spark Talk. What do you need? What do you actually need?
[Pause.]
Nice. Maybe you had a great breakthrough. Maybe you didn’t. That’s not the point. The point is: notice how fast you went to thinking.
So my challenge to you today is this. In your own lives and in your coaching lives, try to find the boots. Listen for the boots. Try to find the pants. Listen for the pants. And then leave some space for the tutu. Thank you.
Frequently asked questions
What does holding space mean in coaching?
Holding space means leaving enough room in a session for the client to find their own answer. In Edward Macdonald's story, he skipped the obvious fix, asked his daughter what she needed, and waited. She came back with a solution he would never have suggested.
Why does holding space help clients have insights?
Macdonald has watched clients' brains on EEG during coaching. A moment of insight arrived with a spike in alpha waves, a relaxed, present state. Research by Kounios and Beeman describes a similar pattern: an alpha burst quiets thinking before the gamma activity linked to an aha moment.
What are boots and pants in coaching?
Boots are the identities, ambitions, and values a client is attached to and won't take off. Pants are the constraints, expectations, and requirements that don't fit over them. Clients often ask for help getting the pants on, which can mean coaching the wrong problem.
How can a coach hold space for someone?
Listen for the boots, listen for the pants, and leave room for an answer neither of you can predict. Macdonald also points to the coach's own pressure to help, look professional, and add value. That pressure crowds the conversation, so noticing it frees up space for the client.

About the speaker
Edward Macdonald, MCC, MBA
Executive coach, applied neuroscience practitioner, founder of Limitless Development.
Edward Macdonald, MCC, MBA, is an executive coach, applied neuroscience practitioner, and founder of Limitless Development. He helps high-performing leaders build the internal capacity for clearer thinking, creative problem-solving, and sustainable performance under pressure. His work blends coaching, behavior change, neurofeedback, biofeedback, and leadership development. In The Spaciousness Advantage, Edward explores how spaciousness helps people see what pressure hides.
Holding space is a core coaching skill. Learn it in the ICF Coaching Certification, where Edward Macdonald, MCC, is one of the coaches who lead the training.
Join a Sample Training ClassTop Coach is our coaching competition series. Watch Top Coach


